Advertisement

Update: Maserati Birdcage At Mecum Isn't A Fake, It's A Reconstruction

Follow Nelson

UPDATE: We were the first on the Web to bring you word that the 1960 Maserati Tipo 61/60 "Birdcage" chassis no. 2459 coming up for auction at the Mecum Monterey Auction to be held during Pebble Beach's classic car week. Today, we received word from Sam Murtaugh at Mecum that the auction description for the car has been updated with more complete information about the car's history and origins.

The new description includes the fact of the original chassis no. 2459's destruction in 1962 and its painstaking reconstruction and certification through the FIA.

Mecum's description goes on to state: "Some internet blogs have called the car a fake and counterfeit. We would like to define fake or counterfeit as words that pertain when you attempt to deceive someone. The history and explanation is fully disclosed on this car.  We do acknowledge that there can be a difference of opinions. The owner/seller’s opinion is he is selling a re-constructed current rendition of the original."

We don't necessarily take offense to the statement, as we simply asked the question, when presented with pertinent evidence, if the car being offered as the original 2459 (as it was at the very least implied in the initial auction description) might not be exactly as it seems--in other words, a fake. With the full disclosure of the car's provenance, Mecum can now offer the car as a reconstruction of the chassis no. 2459 Birdcage in good conscience, and buyers can approach the car with full knowledge of its history.

The matter may be settled as far as Mecum (and its potential bidders) are concerned, but the Maserati lovers at the Autosport forums who first brought the matter to our attention continue to find fault with the car and its status.

ORIGINAL: We just received word through our tip line that the 1960 Maserati Birdcage #2459 going up for auction at the Mecum Monterey Auction during Pebble Beach week is a fake. We haven't been able to confirm one way or the other yet, but the evidence is compelling.

The tipster led us to the Autosport forums, where member RA Historian posted up alleged details on the history of chassis #2459, including a quote from the Oosthoeck/Bollee book The Magnificent Front Engined Birdcages, which states the car originally built with that chassis code was scrapped and used for parts on other Birdcages after a catastrophic end-over-end wreck at Daytona in February, 1962.

RA Historian adds that he has written to Mecum about the issue, and was told in an email by John Kramen at Mecum, "The complete history and fitting of this specific racer is accurately and correctly stated in the website description at www.mecum.com, with information provided by the vehicle principle [sic]. Certainly the spectacular completion by world renowned and respected Birdcage expert Steve Hart in 2010 combined with FIA approval places this historic racer among the most desirable and sought after investment grade sports racers ever produced." That non-response skirts the issue, but does point toward Mecum's ad for the car, which represents it as a "restoration" rather than a reconstruction or replica. The auction description goes on to imply that the car up for auction is one of the remaining 21 original front-engine Birdcages in existence.

The auction description lists the car's vitals as:

  • Chassis# 2459
  • 2.0L engine
  • 5-Speed gearbox
  • DeDion rear end
  • Dunlop 4-wheel disc brakes 
  • First raced at Sebring 12 Hours by Walt Hansgen

We have also contacted Mecum and are waiting on a response.

Even if the Birdcage up for auction isn't the real item, it's still a beautiful, valuable car--just not as valuable or historically significant as it claims to be. That's a fact the bidders should know and Mecum should disclose if true, but at the same time, it wouldn't stop us from bidding on the car--knowingly, and for a reasonable price.

We'll keep you posted if/when we hear from Mecum on the matter or as the situation develops.

Thanks for the tip, Frank!

Advertisement
 
Follow Us

 

Have an opinion?

  • Posting indicates you have read this site's Privacy Policy and Terms of Use
  • Notify me when there are more comments
Comments (7)
  1. Well researched article as you suggest weapons grade racer for sure but $ 1,000, 000 vehicle with a continuous history almost certainly not.
     
    Post Reply
    Vote
    Bad stuff?

  2. With all due respect, this is a ton of BS. The car is a fake, being sold by a man who lied by misrepresenting what this car is. It has ZERO claim to the chassis number it mimics, and is worth strictly what someone wanting a replica will be willing to pay for it. The Mecum auction folks are going to do themselves great damage by sticking with what is simply a lie. They use the meaningless FIA papers as a proof of authenticity, when the FIA does not at all guarantee that authenticity, but simply the conformity of the new car to that of the old, no longer existing example.
    STOP THE BS!!!
     
    Post Reply
    Vote
    Bad stuff?

  3. That the car continues to be referred to as a T60/61 is still a misinterpretation, since Maserati only referred to each Birdcage as a T60 OR T61 but never both. Either way the dye is cast let fun begin.
     
    Post Reply
    Vote
    Bad stuff?

  4. First off, the title is VERY MISLEADING. Secondly, this article makes it seem like there is controversy with this vehicle, when really there is not.
     
    Post Reply
    Vote
    Bad stuff?

  5. As we all know, the Monterey auction is coming up, and they have a different birdcage featured there (2461), but it sure doesn’t seem to be as choice as this one, and it is the one that I hope more ‘experts’ will look deeper into.

    I have been an admirer of the Birdcages for a while, and in researching them, I have found a lot of information, including this article. The best, and seemingly most accurate article about the 2459 is available at http://insidersinvestmentcarforum.blogspot.com/2013/08/rebuilt-vintage-race-cars-can-they.html rather than here, where they seem to be making a story out of nothing.
     
    Post Reply
    Vote
    Bad stuff?

  6. Guess what folks this car is up for sale again at Russo and Steele's at Scottsdale in January, the way I read the blurb it is 2459 with a "frame based on original factory drawings and the RESTORATION (my capitals) completed by noted UK expert Steve Hart.

    No mention of the car being a replica or even reconstruction, google Maserati 2459 and check images and you'll see the chassis plate on this car looks brand spanking new.
     
    Post Reply
    Vote
    Bad stuff?

  7. My understanding is that most of the engine is original to 2459 per this letter: http://www.autocollectorsgarage.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/Steve-Hart-Letter0001.pdf.

    Given that the chassis on these birdcages were wrecked and redone several times save for one – 2455, which has its original chassis – having a big chunk of the original 2459 engine and other 2459 parts plus additional original birdcage parts does make it a legitimate restoration. Plus, all the parts and restoration procedures are documented, and those documents and photographs are readily available.

    How many other birdcages have gone to auction without controversy despite having even less restoration paperwork, and in some cases, less original parts, than 2459
     
    Post Reply
    Vote
    Bad stuff?

 

Have an opinion? Join the conversation!

Advertisement
Advertisement

Take Us With You!

 

Get FREE Dealer Quotes

From dealers near you
Go!
Advertisement

Research New Cars

Go!


 
© 2014 MotorAuthority. All Rights Reserved. MotorAuthority is published by High Gear Media. Stock photography by izmo, Inc. Send us feedback.