Should the American Le Mans Series Be Cancelled?

 

Porsche 911 GT3 R Hybrid at Petit Le Mans, Road Atlanta, October 2010

Porsche 911 GT3 R Hybrid at Petit Le Mans, Road Atlanta, October 2010

The American LeMans Series CANCELLED? –It’s really for the good of the sport.

The American LeMans Series finale for 2010 is a reminder to me why this series should be scrapped and not allowed to continue in its present form.

Sure, this year’s Petit Le Mans drew the same Audi and Peugeot prototypes that slugged it out back in June at 24 Hour race itself. Since PLM is now part of the new Intercontinental Le Mans Cup the factory prototypes were in attendance. Sebring will join its sister track and become one of the seven ILMC events scheduled for 2011. The famed Florida twelve hour enduro, which would probably draw fifty thousand intoxicated party goers just to watch a pedal car contest, will be treated to these two juggernaut manufacturer teams as well as all of the other international LMP1 squads who are planning to compete in next seasons newly minted world sports car circuit.     

It all sounds pretty darn good, don’t it? So why would I send the current ALMS to the garbage and most of the management packing?

Well, aside from Sebring and PLM - the ALMS makes Le Mans sports car racing look badly. It is a joke to many Europeans- and rightly so. There are currently more LMP1 cars on display in the Audi museum than one might find at the typical ALMS event. The few prototype sports cars that are currently there usually just get in the way of what should be the focus for the series- the relatively well subscribed Grand Touring class.

Big bore drivers in small bore cars.

The ALMS prototype car count has gotten so bad that (aside from the big Sebring and Petit races) the rules have been adjusted to allow the lower horsepower LMP2 cars compete with the LMP1’s so that they can have more than three prototype cars running for the overall win. To help fill the field the Braselton brain trust introduced even lower horsepower LeMans Prototype Challenge spec racers (with mostly amateur drivers on board) that have been allowed to take to the track as well.  The purists and most diehard ALMS supporters have greeted the new Challenge class with disdain. Many sports car racing fans wonder what is to become of the series they love.

The last decade of North American sports car racing malaise was brought to you by the Volkswagen-Audi Group.

Who says that a Le Mans series has to have prototypes?  Despite the fact that I personally have liked the sleek LMPs more than any other kind race car, there aren’t enough of them to have a North American racing series. Heck, there never were enough LMP1 cars in the ALMS. It was always just an exhibition of what big bunches of corporate dollars can produce. Every time I saw Audi proclaiming their superiority in the ALMS it reminded me more than a little of Poland in September of 1939.

To their credit, the R18’s were underdogs at LeMans this year. Against the odds they managed prevail and brought home a podium sweep. Audi beat Peugeot with reliability and can crow about it all they like. I hope we see more sports car racing battles like that in the future, but the ALMS victories and multiple titles mean nothing in my opinion. In fact, talking about them is like bragging about beating the crap out of some girl. OK, maybe she was a really good softball player back in high school, but it’s not something that you should be proud of.

How about ALMS for the “poor”?

Instead of hoping that Audi comes back to running a full time mega D Mark effort in the ALMS, maybe people should focus on the one strength the series has going for it: GT cars






 
Follow Us

 

Have an opinion?Join the conversation!

  • Posting indicates you have read this site's Privacy Policy and Terms of Use
  • Notify me when there are more comments
Comments (9)
  1. Kurt, do you think perhaps they should use Supercars? ;-)
    Audi ran R15', unless you are coming back from the future.
     
    Post Reply
    Vote
    Bad stuff?

  2. Wow, way to sink an otherwise cogent argument: By throwing in unrelated political references. I think you were thinking of some other article.
     
    Post Reply
    Vote
    Bad stuff?

  3. Mr. Maxwell,
    As one of the readers above pointed out, it might be worthwhile as part of your investigative responsibility as a journalist (which I highly doubt you have credentials to be) to get your facts straight *before* writing an editorial. The car that won Le Mans was indeed an R15, not an R18, which is the closed top coupe that will be race this year. And as far as making sportscar racing look "badly"... I think the ALMS has done more to further technology and innovation in motorsports than we have seen since the introduction of seat belts and disc brakes since the 1940s, 50s and 60s. As any fan has come to appreciate by now, sportscar racing in the U.S. has an ebb and flow to it that changes it's face constantly. What we are seeing now is not unlike the IMSA days of the 1970s before the Group C/GTP cars came along where GT cars are being embraced, as they are more relevant from a manufacturer standpoint, cheaper and give more "bang for the buck."
    Additionally, I might ask, have you seen the finishes over the past 3 ALMS seasons? Bergmeister and Melo at Sebring? Bergmeister and Magnussen at Laguna Seca? Pagenaud and Fernandez at Long Beach? Surely the Series gets some credit for the great action it puts on the track.
     
    Post Reply
    Vote
    Bad stuff?

  4. Lastly, I wonder if you would suggest that Grand-Am be cancelled as well? That series has struggled with turnout since its inception, not via cars but instead fans. What cars are allowed to race are a farce - tube-frame creations that slap in a factory motor and brakes. I'm confused why a DP class is even necessary. The GT Mazdas are tube-frame, sequential shift, THREE-rotor vehicles that share little in common with the road car other than a large greenhouse. Yet they are dominant year in and year out. Do they not qualify as DP cars then? Maybe with smaller restrictors they could finally put an end to the Riley dominance in the DP "class", which I remind you is populated by chassis that have changed little from their inception in 2003. Sure Grand-Am has car counts much higher than those ALMS but with fields made up mostly of cars that could just as easily be seen racing in a local SCCA club event.
    My point is thus: In a time when economies are hurting everywhere and businesses and manufacturers are struggling to get by without losing their identities, why should the American Le Mans Series be held to a different standard? Their goals are unique, based on their relationship with their fans, sponsors and teams, just as Grand-Am is driven by it's own. A political debate it is not. A source for racing other than go fast and turn left - it is.
     
    Post Reply
    Vote
    Bad stuff?

  5. Mr. Neill
    Yes,I am obviously guilty of having typed "R18" when I meant to say "R15". Worse yet,I caught the mistake while proof reading this piece and yet somehow failed to correct it before sending it off.
    That said,there is is a silver lining to every black cloud. In this case it is your interesting response to what I wrote. But for my mistake you might not have had the impetus you needed to write what you did. You are clearly one of the last die hard ALMS fans -and at this point it takes courage to defend that series.
    Though the beginning of your reply was rather pedantic,it did provide you with an opportunity to attempt to discredit the writer and what had been written about "your" series. Stating opinions(i.e. "I think the ALMS has done more to further technology")instead of admitting to the quantifiable facts (i.e. low LMP count-almost from the start.) was very Atherton like and is probably worthy of a ticket for your wife to the "Green Park" at Sebring.
    Although I never said anything about Grand Am in my article, your follow up post was proof that you are a true believer in the ALMS. The parting shot about "A source for racing other than go fast and turn left-it is." was powerful, even if it was a bit of out of context.
    All in all it was a "World Class" defense of the American Le Mans Series and about what I have come to expect from people of your ilk.
    -KJM
     
    Post Reply
    Vote
    Bad stuff?

  6. Mr. Wilcox- Thanks for the input.
    The whole "Green" thing IS political,IMO. It has no place in motor sports. I didn't bring them in to begin with, I am simply responding to what I find offensive. It would be the same if it was from the "other side" as I am a libertarian.
    The "style over substance",lack of results, questionable statements and lack of credibility from both men are just too similar for me to ignore.
    -KJM
     
    Post Reply
    Vote
    Bad stuff?

  7. BH-I can always count on you.
    Ferrari and Lamborghini are super cars,right? Get rid of the few prototypes ruining the show,(except the classics: Sebring and PLM) replace those cars with another Gallardo,a couple more 458's and a few GT-E McLaren MP4-...whatever they are.(Wait,I don't want to be hammered and discredited by Pedantics R Us again...uh is it -12C? Anyway,it's the car they will race in GT3 before possibly selling them in GT-E form.) -and it will be what I have called for since meeting with the previous head of the ALMS some twelve (12? really?)years ago down in Indy.
    -KJM
     
    Post Reply
    Vote
    Bad stuff?

  8. Not that my opinion carries any weight, but I gotta disagree with you. There is plenty of public interest in ALMS, I have the 2011 season schedule as my desktop backround at work and i always have people looking over my shoulder asking when the next race is, bringing me to my next point, the fact that mainstream media doesnt even mention race dates making difficult for a "casual" race fan to participate regularly.
     
    Post Reply
    Vote
    Bad stuff?

  9. Nick- If there is so much interest in the ALMS why is not going to be live on TV this year?
    The fact that the mainstream media ignores the series says it all. Despite your anecdote concerning your PC background most people don't care about the ALMS.
    My point is that if the embarrassing handful of LMP cars were eliminated and GT cars were the focus there might be more interest.
    It's all moot now. By next year, aside from the Intercontinental Sebring and PLM events,it should be all over given the way things are going.
     
    Post Reply
    Vote
    Bad stuff?

 

Have an opinion?Join the conversation!

Connect with Facebook

Motor Authority. Now with your friends.

Discover stories your friends read.
Share stories more easily.
You control what you share.
Learn more

Research New Cars

Go!


 
© 2011 MotorAuthority. All Rights Reserved. MotorAuthority is published by High Gear Media. Stock photography by Homestar, LLC. Send us feedback.