Advertisement

Hot Hatch Rivalry: MINI Cooper S vs Volkswagen GTI


Two of the best hot hatchback on the market today.

Two of the best hot hatchback on the market today.

Enlarge Photo

 Ask a gear head what was the first “hot hatchback,” the majority of them will answer with the Volkswagen Golf GTI, which was first produced in 1976 but didn’t reach American shores until 1983. Some will say the Mini Cooper S, first appearing in 1963 and was a hot hatchback in every respect except lacking an actual hatchback.

Here at Sports Car Monitor, we like to take looks at The Car Connection’s Bottom Line reviews and pit cars against each other. This week it’s going to be the 2010 MINI Cooper S versus the 2010 Volkswagen GTI. This comparison is helped by the fact that both cars are two doors and start at nearly the same price-point, $23,000 for the MINI Cooper S and $23,290 for the Volkswagen GTI.

For Styling the MINI Cooper S wins. It has retro-futuristic styling that mimics the original MINI and has an array of options that can customize the car to the owner’s taste. The interior is also well designed with the only exception is the center speedometer. The Golf shares its body with the regular Golf but comes with its own distinct traits that can be pointed out at a glance.

Performance is very similar between the two. The 200 hp GTI rips 0-60 in 6.7 seconds while the 172 hp Cooper S manages to 7 seconds. The MINI has the best shifting manual, but the GTI comes with the superior automatic with its DSG transmission. Both cars are some of the best handling factory front-wheel-drive cars, though the Cooper S run-flat tires increases ride harshness.

The interior experience is nearly the same, Both cars offer enough room for six-footers up front, but at the cost of rear seat occupants, thought the GTI has more room than the Cooper S. Both cars benefit with those rear seats folded down and give owners the cargo capacity that hot hatches are know for. As written in the GTI Bottom line, “The upright shape and sizable glass areas give the GTI great visibility, and the feel isn't unlike that of the MINI Cooper.”

For Safety, the GTI has a slight advantage over the Cooper S. Both cars come equipped with anti-lock brakes, six airbags, and stability control. They also come with a variety of four-t- five star NHTSA ratings. However the GTI comes standard with traction control while it’s an option on the Cooper S.

What kills the Cooper S in options is that the Volkswagen comes with plenty of standard equipment, while the MINI features are almost all options. An example is that the GTI comes standard with USB and Bluetooth compatibility which will cost extra on the Cooper S.

So in the end, it appears that the 2010 Volkswagen GTI edges out the MINI Cooper S. Both are excellent hot hatches, but the GTI gives better value per money and safety.

But this is just an on-paper comparison. Hot hatchbacks are always cool, and these two are prime examples of what this segment has to offer.

Advertisement
 
Follow Us

 

Have an opinion?

  • Posting indicates you have read this site's Privacy Policy and Terms of Use
  • Notify me when there are more comments
Comments (2)
  1. this is very comprehensive study.
    I have driven both hatches. The mini is fun to drive in curves and sharp turns . The gear shifter at the steering wheel is just amazing!! It is a small car for everything, not just the parking.. i even drove on the bicycle line one day =O ! The mini also, has a hotter looks than the GTI, where while driving the mini i can notice the number of hot chicks spotting the car while in the GTI the number is much less as due to the similarity of the regular Golf shape.
    The GTI is an excellent car too. The DSG gear bos is amazin , the Audio system is awesome and rear passenger capacity is better than the mini. Acceleration from 0 to 60 MPH has stronger grip than the mini. The Bi-Xenon head lambs are excellent for night traveling. If I had to choose between the 2 of them i would go for the GTI however, there are few things i don't like about it including the small size of the side view mirror .. i really wonder why VW don't just make it normal size like any other car. Also, the car vibration where i feel like I'm riding my 1,600 cc Harley Davidson sometimes!
     
    Post Reply
    Vote
    Bad stuff?

  2. this is very comprehensive study. I have driven both hatches. The mini is fun to drive in curves and sharp turns . The gear shifter at the steering wheel is just amazing!! It is a small car for everything, not just the parking.. i even drove on the bicycle line one day! The mini also, has a hotter looks than the GTI, where while driving the mini i can notice the number of hot chicks spotting the car while in the GTI the number is much less as due to the similarity of the regular Golf shape. The GTI is an excellent car too. The DSG gear bos is amazin , the Audio ystem is awesome and rear passenger capacity is better than the mini. Acceleration from 0 to 60 MPH has stronger grip than the mini. The Bi-Xenon head lambs are excellent for night traveling. If I had to choose between the 2 of them i would go for the GTI however, there are few things i don't like about it including the small size of the side view mirror .. i really wonder why VW dont just make it normal size like any other car. Also, the car vibration where i feel like I'm riding my 1,600 cc Harley Davidson sometimes!
     
    Post Reply
    Vote
    Bad stuff?

 

Have an opinion? Join the conversation!

Advertisement
Advertisement

Take Us With You!

 

Get FREE Dealer Quotes

From dealers near you
Go!
Advertisement

Research New Cars

Go!

Related Used Listings

Browse used listings in your area.


 
© 2014 MotorAuthority. All Rights Reserved. MotorAuthority is published by High Gear Media. Stock photography by izmo, Inc. Send us feedback.