By
Nelson Ireson
Nelson Ireson
Editor
BIO
Nelson is an Editor at High Gear Media focusing on reviewing cars and covering the hottest topics in luxury and performance cars, car culture, and...
More
LATEST ARTICLE
2012 BMW M6 Preview
With the new 6-Series Gran Coupe, the revised 6-Series Coupe and Convertible, and now the 2012 M6...
Read More
- #3LEADERBOARD RANK
- 5124ARTICLES CONTRIBUTED
- 187COMMENTS POSTED
Oft maligned for its highly derivative design style, the Chinese auto industry has at times seemed offended by accusations of copying, and at others simply indifferent – as if it were
perfectly natural and acceptable. The latter theory is likely to be put to the test even more hotly than it already has, as the EU has approved the controversial Shuanghuan CEO and Zheijang Jonway UFO clone cars for sale, and the first shipments will be arriving in Germany in mere days.
China Automobile Deutschland, the German importer bringing the Zheijang Jonway UFO and
Shuanghuan Automobile CEO into the EU, says both cars have received approval for sale, and will be offered in February. The UFO very closely resembles the
Toyota RAV-4, while the CEO is a near-exact copy of the
BMW X5. Toyota thinks its product will acquit itself well despite the similarities in looks, and has neglected to file legal charges to impede the import of the clone cars. BMW, on the other hand, has already initiated
legal proceedings to prohibit the sale of the CEO in Europe and elsewhere on the grounds that it infringes BMW’s intellectual property. A decision in that case isn’t expected until later this year, however, reports
Automotive News Europe.
Price, as much as looks, may be a motivator for the suit seeking to stop the copycats from coming to Europe. The CEO will be priced at a very attractive €25,900 to start, which undercuts the BMW by more than half – an entry level X5 starts at €52,500 in Germany. And although
Toyota seems unconcerned with Zheijang Jonway’s mimicry, the UFO starts at just €15,900, while the real RAV-4 will run you €27,165 in the home of Bratwurst und Sauerkraut. Perhaps it’s time Toyota got worried. On the other hand, the automotive industry isn’t an easy business, and Toyota’s acumen is hard to question. Maybe their assessment of the Chinese vehicle’s quality is dead-on, and the problem will effectively solve itself. But that’s a pretty risky gamble.
Have an opinion?Join the conversation!
By MARK Posted: 1/23/2008 2:04am PST
By HECTOR Posted: 1/23/2008 6:26am PST
In the case of these Chinese copies what you are getting is a truly substandard piece of crap which truly shouldn't be allowed on our roads.
By SuperSkyline89 Posted: 1/23/2008 7:48am PST
Toyota might actually be doing the smart thing by not suing. That gives them the opportunity to see how BMW's trial goes and gauge their own chances of winning. Better than spending millions on a trial that isn't a guaranteed victory.
I wonder what kinds of ads BMW and Toyota will make now. I'm thinking something along the lines of the KIA ads that compare their cars to BMW's saying KIAs have less cup holder but they're much cheaper. 'The Chinese might save you $10,000 but is that really going to help you here" and they pan to a crash scene of a Toyota RAV4 with the Chinese clone where the Toyota driver is fine and the other driver got launched through the windshield and is lying in a mangled heap meters away.
By Gus Posted: 1/23/2008 10:46am PST
Parts and pieces were falling off from day one.
Never, ever again...
Have an opinion?Join the conversation!